L.A. Weekly article published on November 19, 2008
(click here for full article)
…City Attorney Rocky Delgadillo played a key role in bringing the [settlement deal with the billboard companies] to the Council two years ago. But much of the responsibility also lies with Councilman Garcetti, the fresh-faced enviro who runs the council with a strong hand, pushes hard for unanimous votes, and rewards his favored members with plum committee assignments.
Garcetti, who for five years has tooled around L.A. in an EV1 electric car, long ignored criticism of the sweetheart deal he helped to push through. Despite outcry from Valley, Hollywood and Westside residents, it wasn’t until a few weeks ago, amidst the erupting anger in Silver Lake - in a neighborhood not far from Garcetti’s own, where he has many friends - that Garcetti, a billboard enabler, began to question himself.
“It was probably a mistake,” Garcetti told The New York Times on Nov. 5. A week later, he went further, telling L.A. Weekly,” It was a really bad decision,” in which he was “blinded” by a promise that some illegal billboards in his own area, Echo Park, would be removed…
….For weeks this fall, Garcetti seemed stunned by what he and the City Council had unleashed. Long a backer of supersized outdoor advertising, Garcetti suddenly switched sides…
…But by the time the powerful City Council president had taken an interest, it was two years too late. Residents want the signs gone, but an estimated 50 recently switched-on LED displays - the behemoth at the intersection of Topanga Canyon and Victory boulevards that can be seen from a Santa Monica Mountains overlook; or a piercing sign that floods a bedroom in Cahuenga Pass - are almost certainly here to stay.
They are unaffected by the six-month moratorium now under consideration. Legal experts say that the eyesore will loom over charming Silver Lake Boulevard for years. And Garcetti is already lowering expectations, using the term “extremist” to describe any plan to actually ban LED billboards…
…Few environmentalists or anti-clutter activists trust Villaraigosa, Delgadillo or Garcetti to hold tough, once the proposed moratorium ends in mid-2009. For years, their efforts to address L.A.’s worsening clutter have sputtered and backfired, including Garcetti’s televised - and, it turns out, hollow - public vow two years ago to remove 15 illegal billboards on Echo Park Boulevard not far from his own “green” home recently featured in Dwell magazine. He has managed to remove just two…
…Nobody - not Villaraigosa, Garcetti or any of the other City Hall politicians who have taken money from outdoor advertisers or received free campaign billboard ads from them - publicly questioned Delgadillo’s behavior. He brought to the City Council a “settlement” he had hammered out with Clear Channel Outdoor and CBS Outdoor. The odd deal, never debated by the neighborhoods it would affect, was quickly accepted by Garcetti and the council, and signed by Villaraigosa.
Today, there is little disagreement that it was a major capitulation to the billboard giants, unparalled in the United States. Yet Garcetti is still confused, claiming a few weeks ago on KPPC radio that the settlement allowing digital conversions was a result of the city losing its case in court.
In fact, the city won. Garcetti now tells the Weekly, “it is embarrassing” that he, the Council, Villaraigosa and Delgadillo all settled, knowing they had won in court…
…Garcetti clearly doesn’t like his unflattering new image. He ran for office as a green candidate and lives the Silver Lake ethos - except that he has taken eight contributions from outdoor advertising companies, according to the City Ethics Commission.